Okay, really -- $4.50? Yes, you can buy TWO tickets for the price of $9 for any movie purchase on www.fandango.com. The tickets are worth up to $15 per ticket, which when added to the price of a New York movie $13 + $2 fandango surcharge, you're ticket is covered.
The special sale is going on right now at www.livingsocial.com. However, you have to hurry because you will have until 9 AM tomorrow morning (Thursday) to purchase them.